Why 87% of Contractor Marketing Fails (And the 3 Things That Actually Work)

If you're a contractor in Ontario who's tried marketing before and felt like you threw money into a black hole, you're not alone. Industry data shows that 87% of contractor marketing campaigns fail to generate positive ROI within their first six months.

That's a staggering failure rate. But here's the thing: it's not because marketing doesn't work for contractors. It's because most contractors are doing it completely wrong.

After working with hundreds of contractors across Niagara Falls, St. Catharines, Hamilton, and Burlington, we've identified exactly why most contractor marketing in Ontario fails and, more importantly, the three things that actually work.

The 5 Deadly Sins of Contractor Marketing

Before we get to what works, let's talk about what doesn't. These are the most common mistakes we see contractors make:

1. Spray and Pray Advertising

You've probably done this: bought a Facebook ad, maybe sponsored a Little League team, put your logo on a truck, and hoped something would stick. This scattershot approach wastes 60-70% of your marketing budget because you're reaching people who don't need your services right now.

A Hamilton roofer we spoke with spent $4,200 on Facebook ads in 2025 and got exactly three calls, none of which converted. Why? Because he was advertising to everyone instead of targeting homeowners in specific neighbourhoods with older roofs.

2. Inconsistency

Marketing once or twice and then stopping is like going to the gym twice and expecting abs. Effective contractor marketing requires consistent touchpoints over 3-6 months before you see real results.

The average homeowner needs to see your message 7-12 times before they remember your name when they need a contractor. One flyer drop or one month of ads won't cut it.

3. No Clear Call to Action

We've reviewed hundreds of contractor ads and flyers. Most of them say something like "Quality work at affordable prices" with a phone number at the bottom. That's not a call to action, that's wallpaper.

Related: CAN-TAP Verified Review Systems — Ships from Port Colborne, Ontario.

Your marketing needs to tell people exactly what to do next: "Call for a free quote," "Schedule your inspection today," "Text 'ROOF' to get pricing in 5 minutes."

4. Ignoring Your Google Business Profile

Your Google Business Profile is the single most important marketing asset you have, and most contractors treat it like an afterthought. 73% of consumers say positive reviews make them trust a local business more, yet the average contractor in Ontario has fewer than 12 reviews.

If you're not actively getting reviews and optimizing your profile, you're invisible to homeowners searching "roofer near me" or "plumber St. Catharines."

5. No Follow-Up System

Here's a painful truth: 80% of leads require 5+ follow-ups to convert, but most contractors give up after one or two attempts. You're letting thousands of dollars slip through your fingers because you don't have a system to stay in touch with prospects.

The 3 Things That Actually Work

Now for the good news. After testing dozens of strategies with contractors across Ontario, three approaches consistently deliver results:

1. Hyper-Targeted Direct Mail to the Right Neighbourhoods

Digital ads are noisy and easy to ignore. But a well-designed flyer that lands in the mailbox of a homeowner in a 25-year-old neighbourhood? That gets attention.

Related: Custom Signs & Banners — Ships from Port Colborne, Ontario.

Direct mail to contractors delivers an average ROI of 29% when done correctly. The key is targeting:

• Neighbourhoods with homes built 15-30 years ago (prime time for roof replacements, window upgrades, HVAC systems)
• High-income postal codes where homeowners can afford your services
• Areas within 15 minutes of your location so you can actually service them profitably

A Welland roofer used this strategy with our Block Buster campaign (500 doors, $697) and got 11 calls in three weeks. He closed four jobs worth $31,000. That's a 4,350% ROI.

The magic isn't just the mail itself, it's the combination of the right message, right neighbourhood, and right timing. We help contractors in Niagara Falls, St. Catharines, and across Ontario identify exactly which streets to target based on housing age, income data, and service need probability.

2. A Review Generation System That Runs on Autopilot

You need reviews. Not five or ten. You need 50+ to dominate local search and win trust. But asking for reviews manually is painful and inconsistent.

NFC review cards are the game-changer. These are tap-to-review cards you hand to happy customers at job completion. They tap their phone, and they're instantly taken to your Google review page. No typing, no friction, no excuses.

Contractors using NFC review cards see 3-5x more review submissions compared to text or email requests. A Burlington HVAC contractor went from 8 reviews to 64 reviews in four months using this system. His call volume increased by 40% without spending another dollar on ads.

3. Seasonal Campaign Timing

Most contractors market when they're slow. That's backwards. You should market 8-12 weeks BEFORE your busy season so the leads are ready to convert when you have capacity.

Here's the Ontario contractor marketing calendar that works:

• January-February: Market spring services (landscaping, exterior painting, roof inspections)
• April-May: Market summer projects (decks, pools, windows)
• July-August: Market fall services (eavestrough cleaning, furnace tune-ups)
• October-November: Market winter prep and indoor renovations

A St. Catharines landscaper started marketing in January instead of April and booked his entire spring season by mid-March. He increased revenue by 34% and eliminated the feast-or-famine cycle.

The Brutal Truth About Marketing for Contractors

Marketing works. But only if you do it right. The reason 87% of campaigns fail is because contractors treat marketing like a lottery ticket instead of a system.

The contractors who succeed with marketing do three things consistently:

1. They target specific neighbourhoods with direct mail campaigns

Related: Direct Mail Lead Generation — Ships from Port Colborne, Ontario.

2. They build review momentum with frictionless systems

3. They market before they're desperate for work

If you're ready to stop wasting money on marketing that doesn't work, it's time to try what actually does. Get a free quote on a targeted direct mail campaign that reaches the exact homeowners most likely to need your services in the next 60-90 days.

Why Direct Mail Still Crushes Digital for Contractors

Digital ads have their place, but for contractors, direct mail outperforms digital by 3-to-1 in conversion rates. Here's why:

• Physical mail gets 100% delivery (no spam filters, no ad blockers)
• Homeowners spend 30% more time reviewing mail than digital ads
• Mail has a 4-week shelf life (sits on the counter, gets looked at multiple times)
• It's impossible to scroll past like a Facebook ad

When you combine direct mail with a strong offer, clear call to action, and precise targeting, you create a marketing machine that generates consistent leads month after month.

How to Fix Your Contractor Marketing Right Now

If your marketing isn't working, here's your action plan:

This Week:

• Claim and optimize your Google Business Profile
• Order NFC review cards and commit to collecting 10 reviews this month
• Identify your top 3 target neighbourhoods based on home age and income

This Month:

• Launch a direct mail campaign to 250-500 doors in one target neighbourhood
• Set up a simple CRM or spreadsheet to track every lead and follow up 5+ times
• Create one seasonal promotion that aligns with upcoming customer needs

This Quarter:

• Hit 25+ Google reviews minimum
• Test and refine your direct mail messaging based on response rates
• Build a 12-month marketing calendar so you're always marketing BEFORE you need work

The contractors making six and seven figures aren't smarter than you. They just stopped doing marketing that doesn't work and started doing the three things that do.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: How much should contractors spend on marketing?

A: Industry standard is 5-10% of gross revenue. A contractor doing $500,000/year should invest $25,000-$50,000 in marketing. Start small with a $397-$697 test campaign and scale what works.

Q: How long does it take to see results from contractor marketing?

A: Direct mail campaigns typically generate calls within 7-14 days. Review generation shows results in 30-60 days. Full marketing systems (combining multiple tactics) deliver consistent ROI within 90-120 days.

Q: Is direct mail still effective in 2026?

A: Absolutely. Direct mail response rates have actually increased as digital channels become oversaturated. Contractors see 3-5% response rates on well-targeted campaigns, compared to 0.5-1% on most digital ads.

Q: What's the best way to get Google reviews as a contractor?

A: NFC review cards handed to customers at job completion have the highest conversion rate (30-40%). Email and text requests convert at 5-10%. Never buy fake reviews, they'll get your profile suspended.

Q: Should I hire a marketing agency or do it myself?

A: Most general marketing agencies don't understand contractor businesses. Look for specialists who focus on home services and can show you case studies with real ROI numbers. DIY marketing works if you have time and follow proven systems, but most contractors are better off partnering with experts who can execute while they focus on operations.

---

Published by Niagara Stands Out — serving contractors and businesses across Ontario since 2019. Based in Port Colborne, ON. Ships Canada-wide. Get a free quote →